10 Hidden Gems in Carmel, Indiana for Locals and Visitors in 2025

Our curated list of the city’s best-kept secrets (and some not-so-secret favorites) we think you’ll love in 2025.

There’s no denying that Carmel, Indiana is one of the Midwest’s most lively cities. When people picture Carmel, things like roundabouts with a shiny finish, high-end boutiques, and hiking trails with a view might come to mind.

But beneath the gloss of this innovative city, there’s a scene full of character, passion, and craftsmanship.

Hidden away among Carmel’s artisan shops and award-winning public spaces, there are spaces locals know and love (but not all tourists do).

Whether you’re a first-time visitor to Carmel or a local resident looking for new experiences, we’ve curated the perfect list of Carmel Indiana hidden gems for locals and visitors in 2025. We even know the spot to visit for elevated style and craftsmanship.

1. Peace Water Winery

Say what? If you love wine, this Carmel family-owned winery imports Napa Valley wines and has a cool urban-chic tasting space. The secret that not all visitors know? 50% of their profits go to charity. Now that tastes even better, doesn’t it?

2. Carmel Arts & Design District Murals

Ah, yes. The Arts District is a popular one in Carmel. But not everyone knows about the hidden alleyway murals in Carmel’s Arts District. These colorful masterpieces are perfect for finding hidden photo spots, and it’s the immersive art experience that you’ll love because it’s always changing.

3. The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers

The Cake Bake Shop has interiors so dazzling that you feel like royalty just walking in the door. From the pink chandeliers to the sparkling white accents, this place is Insta-worthy—but it’s also known for its over-the-top desserts and afternoon teas.

4. Cool Creek Park & Nature Center

If you’re looking for less crowded spaces, look no further than Cool Creek Park & Nature Center. Covering 90-acres of nature and featuring boardwalks, hiking trails, and a sweet little nature center, this is one of Carmel’s go-to spots for hiking, bird-watching, and enjoying nature for all ages.

5. 3UP Rooftop Bar

Hidden above Anthony’s Chophouse is a secret that locals know: 3UP. This elevated rooftop lounge, with stellar views, small plates, and handcrafted cocktails is a trendy under-the-radar spot perfect for date nights or after-work drinks with a view.

6. All Things Carmel

Perfect for finding the perfect souvenir that isn’t run-of-the-mill, this adorable Carmel shop has gifts and products that celebrate everything local. From Carmel-branded apparel to artisan-made gifts, this place is for those looking for locally crafted treasures they won’t find anywhere else.

7. The Great American Songbook Foundation Gallery

Hidden inside the impressive The Palladium, Carmel, The Great American Songbook Foundation Gallery is a small but mighty museum that pays tribute to the music that’s made America great. With a rotating collection of artifacts, memorabilia, and even live music, this is a culture and music lover’s dream.

8. Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream

For Ice cream lovers ice cream is ice cream right? Maybe, if you’re not familiar with Carmel’s favorite, Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream. Serving up made-from-scratch, freshly made ice cream every day since 1945, locals love it and tourists often overlook this delectable treat. Try the one-of-a-kind flavors like Graham Central Station or Blueberry Cobbler.

9. Carmel Farmers Market (Summer & Winter Editions)

Yes, it’s a farmers market. But it’s an elevated one. Featuring live chef demonstrations, live music, and more than 70 vendors offering gourmet bites and artisan goods, Carmel’s market is more of a weekend destination than a stop on your shopping list. Bonus points: you’ll find some unique local brands and goods.

10. Carmel Tailoring & Fine Clothier - Best Custom Suit Tailor Shop in Carmel, Indiana

If you’re in the market for style, precision, and refinement, look no further than Carmel Tailoring & Fine Clothier, Carmel’s sartorial crown jewel. Nestled minutes away from the Carmel Arts & Design District, this family-owned and operated business offers made-to-measure and bespoke tailoring services that will make your dreams come true.

Available fabrics include world-renowned brands, such as Zegna TROFEO, Loro Piana, Holland & Sherry, and Scabal.

Expert clothiers and tailors work with you every step of the way in the custom process, from helping you find the perfect fabric to making sure it fits your body perfectly, to customizing your personal style with unique buttons, lapels, linings, and more.

Whether you’re headed to a business meeting, a wedding, a black-tie affair, or just want to spice up your wardrobe with a custom sports jacket or suit, this is the place. Carmel Tailoring also offers off-the-rack selections if you want to upgrade your look without the wait.

What makes them unique? Attention to detail, personalized fittings, and service that’s second-to-none. They don’t just tailor suits, they create legacies in cloth and craftsmanship.

Why Carmel Indiana Hidden Gems Matter in 2025

Carmel, Indiana continues to grow as one of the Midwest’s top destinations for families and young professionals looking for the best in living, shopping, and culture. But beyond the awards and glossy surfaces of this forward-thinking city are artisans, creators, and innovators worth supporting, and Carmel locals know this.

Whether you’re visiting Carmel in the future, moving to Indiana, or you’re a local resident looking for a change of pace, these hidden gems in Carmel, Indiana are the lesser-known experiences you need to have an authentic slice of local life. But when it comes to dressing the part? That’s when you turn to Carmel Tailoring & Fine Clothier, the number one place for men who take pride in dressing well and looking their best.